StillSparkly
All guides

Guide ·

Where to Sell Handmade Jewelry Online

Short answer: start where handmade shoppers already are (Etsy), build your own site and social following for repeat buyers, and add channels that fit your work. StillSparkly is a jewelry-only US marketplace that welcomes handmade pieces, with free listing and a flat 8% commission. It suits one-of-a-kind pieces more than designs you sell in quantity.

Your main options

Etsy

Etsy is where you’ll find buyers who are specifically looking for handmade. Handmade is its core category, and it supports variations, quantities, and personalization. The downside is that the fees stack up (listing, 6.5% transaction, processing, and Offsite Ads on some sales), and search is crowded, so standing out takes strong photos and steady listing. Wondering whether to stay? See the best Etsy alternatives for jewelry sellers.

Your own website

Your own site works best if you already have an audience. A store on a platform like Shopify or Squarespace gives you your own brand, prices, and customer list with no marketplace commission. You do pay a subscription and payment processing, though, and nobody finds you unless you send them there (a beautiful site with no traffic is a pretty lonely place).

Amazon Handmade

Amazon Handmade suits makers who can produce in volume and handle Amazon’s expectations on shipping and service. You apply to join, and Amazon charges a referral fee on each sale.

Craft fairs, markets, and boutiques

Selling in person is best for pieces people want to see and try on. You pay booth fees upfront, and boutique consignment takes a share of each sale, but the person who bought earrings at your table in May often becomes a repeat online customer.

StillSparkly

StillSparkly suits one-of-a-kind pieces that would stand out in a jewelry-only catalog. It’s a peer-to-peer marketplace for every kind of jewelry, and handmade is a first-class category there. (The jewelry resale sites, Worthy, Louped, and GEMGEM, take fine resale pieces only, so new handmade work is out.) Listing is free and the commission is 8% of the item price, with no separate processing fee. Mark a piece as handmade to show the Handmade badge; shoppers can filter for it, as well as by metal, stone shape, setting, chain type and length, and hoops by diameter, a filter you won’t find on eBay or Etsy. Be aware of the limits: each listing is a single piece (no quantities or variations), sellers and buyers must be in the US, and the marketplace is new, with many shoppers browsing vintage and pre-owned pieces alongside handmade.

Instagram, TikTok, and Pinterest

Think of these as where people discover you. Show your process and your new pieces (people love watching a ring come together), and send them to wherever you actually sell.

Fees compared

MarketplaceSeller fees (US)Keep on a $100 sale
StillSparkly8% of the item price; free to list$92
Etsy6.5% + 3% + $0.25, plus $0.20 to listCharged on shipping too. Offsite Ads add 15% on ad-driven sales (12%, and mandatory, once a shop passes $10,000 a year).$90.05
eBay15% + $0.40 per orderCharged on shipping and sales tax too. 9% on jewelry over $5,000. Promoted listings cost extra.$84.60

Fees checked October 2026 on each platform’s own fee page (linked) and they change, so confirm before you list. “Keep on a $100 sale” assumes the buyer pays shipping and counts only seller fees. Full StillSparkly fee details: what you’ll earn.

When StillSparkly is a good fit for makers

StillSparkly makes sense if you make one-of-a-kind or small-batch pieces and want another place to list them without listing fees, you like the idea of your work being shown among jewelry only, and you’re in the US.

It isn’t the right main channel if you rely on custom orders, personalization, or listings with many variations; Etsy or your own site handles those better. Read how the Handmade badge works and what StillSparkly is and who it’s for.

Tips for selling handmade jewelry online

Wherever you sell, say exactly what the materials are: sterling, gold-filled, plated, or base metal. Buyers search for those words, and our gold-filled vs plated guide explains what each one means.

Show the piece worn, for scale, as well as on a plain background (a pendant that looks huge on a white backdrop can turn out to be dainty on a neck). Our guide on how to photograph jewelry walks through it.

And price for your materials, your time, and every channel’s fees, so a sale anywhere is worth making. Most makers end up selling in two or three places, and that’s fine. Start with the one where your buyers already are, and add the next when you’re ready.

Frequently asked questions

Where is the best place to sell handmade jewelry online?

Etsy has the largest audience actively shopping for handmade jewelry, so it's the usual starting point. Your own website gives you the most control and no marketplace commission, but you have to bring the traffic. Amazon Handmade reaches Amazon shoppers if you're accepted. StillSparkly, a jewelry-only US marketplace with free listing and a flat 8% commission, works as an additional channel for one-of-a-kind pieces.

Can I sell handmade jewelry on StillSparkly?

Yes. Handmade jewelry is welcome alongside vintage and pre-owned pieces. Mark a piece as handmade and it shows a Handmade badge, and shoppers can filter for handmade. Each listing is a single piece, so it suits one-of-a-kind work better than items you sell in quantity.

Should I sell handmade jewelry on more than one site?

Usually, yes. Most makers combine a marketplace for discovery with their own site or social accounts for repeat customers, plus in-person markets. Keep prices consistent across channels.

Related guides

Make jewelry? List it here too.

Free to list, 8% only when it sells. Mark pieces as handmade so they show the Handmade badge.