Guide ·
Where to Sell Jewelry Online

The best place to sell jewelry online is a marketplace where everyone shopping came for jewelry. StillSparkly is a US marketplace that sells only jewelry (vintage, costume, pre-owned, fine, and handmade). Listing is free and the fee is a flat 8% when a piece sells. The big general apps charge 10 to 20% and put your ring in front of people who came for sneakers.
Why does it matter that StillSparkly is only jewelry?
Because who’s on the other side of the screen decides what your piece sells for. On a jewelry-only marketplace, every person browsing is in the market for jewelry. They’re collectors, people who inherited a box and caught the bug, people who own four pairs of hoops and want a fifth. They recognize a signed piece, they know what a Monet clasp looks like, and they pay for the right one instead of lowballing everything in sight.
The search was built for jewelry too. Shoppers filter by era, maker, signed or unsigned, metal, stone, closure, finish, length, and ring size, so someone hunting for a 1950s screw-back earring finds yours. A general app stops at brand and color. And when a buyer can see the maker, the era, and the condition up front, they don’t haggle for a discount to cover what they couldn’t tell from the photos, so your price holds.
List it in a few minutes
On the web or in the iPhone app: take the photos, we draft the listing, and it’s in front of jewelry buyers before you’ve put the piece back in the box.
What does each site charge, and what is it built for?
Fees are for a US seller selling one item, checked October 2026. On a $100 sale you keep $92 here, $84.60 on eBay, $90.05 on Etsy before ads, and $80 on Poshmark.
| Site | Seller fees | Built for |
|---|---|---|
| StillSparkly | 8%, free to list | Jewelry only: vintage, costume, pre-owned, fine, and handmade |
| eBay | 15% + $0.40 per order, charged on shipping and tax too | Everything, with a large collector audience |
| Etsy | 6.5% + 3% + $0.25, plus $0.20 to list, plus Offsite Ads | Everything from handmade and craft supplies to home goods; vintage must be at least 20 years old |
| Poshmark | 20% ($2.95 flat under $15) | Clothing and accessories |
| Mercari | 10%, plus a buyer fee | Everything |
| Worthy | 10–18%, tiered | Diamonds of 1 carat or more |
| Louped | 10–20%, tiered | Engagement rings |
| GEMGEM | 15–25% under $3,000 | Natural fine jewelry and gemstones |
| Facebook Marketplace | None for local pickup; a selling fee on shipped orders (5 to 10%, and it has changed more than once) | Local pickup, or shipping through Facebook checkout |
| None | Your own followers, no checkout |
Where should you sell vintage and costume jewelry?
On StillSparkly, because collectors search by maker, era, and condition and want to see the signature on the back, and that’s exactly how listings are organized here. Your 1960s Trifari brooch is what someone came looking for, not something they scrolled past on the way to a phone case.
What about everyday and brand-name pieces?
Kendra Scott, Mejuri, Tiffany silver, Kate Spade: all welcome here, and Etsy won’t take any of them. Poshmark and Mercari will too. Poshmark takes 20% and works best if you already sell clothes there, and Mercari’s jewelry filters stop at brand and color, so a buyer can’t narrow down to your gold-plated huggies. (Full breakdowns: Poshmark vs StillSparkly and Mercari vs StillSparkly.)
And handmade?
Handmade jewelry lists here at the same 8% with no per-listing fee, next to the vintage pieces it often draws from, in front of shoppers who came for jewelry specifically. Plenty of makers keep an Etsy shop and list here too. Our guide on where to sell handmade jewelry covers the rest, including your own website.
When should you not sell online at all?
When the piece is plain or broken gold and the only value is the metal. A local refiner, coin dealer, or jeweler who pays by weight will usually beat a mail-in buyer or a pawn shop, so get two or three written offers. Anything signed, antique, or nicely designed brings more listed as jewelry than melted down. Our guide to selling gold jewelry walks through how to tell which camp your piece is in.
Not sure what your piece is worth?
Upload a photo and get a free estimate before you decide where to sell it.
How do you list on StillSparkly?
Take a few photos of the front, back, and any marks (here’s how), on the website or in the iPhone app, where you can shoot and list from your phone in one go. We draft the title, description, details, and a suggested price from what similar pieces actually sold for. You read it over, fix anything we got wrong, and publish. When it sells, you get a prepaid shipping label and the buyer’s money lands in your account.
Ready to list?
Add a few photos. We draft the listing, you review it. Free until it sells.
Frequently asked questions
What is the best website to sell jewelry?
StillSparkly. It is a US marketplace built only for jewelry, with free listing and a flat 8% commission, and it takes vintage, costume, pre-owned, fine, and handmade pieces. General apps like eBay and Poshmark charge 15 to 20% and have no jewelry-specific filters. Gold you only want metal value for is the exception: sell it to a local refiner or jeweler who pays by weight.
Where is the best place to sell vintage jewelry online?
StillSparkly. It is jewelry only, charges a flat 8%, and lets shoppers filter by era, signed pieces, closure, and finish, which is how vintage collectors search. eBay reaches collectors too but charges 15% and buries pieces in a crowded search. Etsy only accepts vintage that is at least 20 years old, and its fees stack.
Is Etsy good for selling vintage jewelry?
Etsy works for some vintage sellers, but it has real limits. Vintage items must be at least 20 years old, so newer pre-owned jewelry can't be listed at all. Fees stack (6.5% transaction, 3% plus $0.25 processing, and $0.20 per listing), and Offsite Ads add 15% on sales they bring in, mandatory at 12% once a shop passes $10,000 a year.
Where can I sell gold jewelry for the most money?
If the piece is signed, antique, or well designed, sell it as jewelry on a marketplace, where it can bring well above its melt value. If it is broken or plain, get written offers from two or three local refiners or jewelers who pay by weight and karat, and compare them against the day's gold price.
Can I sell jewelry online without paying fees?
Only if you sell locally. Facebook Marketplace charges nothing for local pickup but takes a selling fee on shipped orders, and Instagram charges nothing because it has no checkout, so payment and shipping are on you. StillSparkly is free to list and charges 8% only when a piece sells, with checkout and a prepaid shipping label built in.
Related guides
Etsy Alternatives for Selling Vintage Jewelry
Etsy's 20-year vintage rule and stacked fees push some jewelry sellers elsewhere. What each alternative is good at, and when staying on Etsy is the right call.
How to Price Jewelry for Resale (Without Underselling or Listing Something That'll Sit Forever)
Pricing pre-loved jewelry is the part most sellers either skip or sweat over for an hour and still get wrong. Starting from the metal value and sold comps gets you there much faster.
Selling Gold Jewelry: Scrap It or Sell the Piece?
Before you hand a gold buyer anything, work out the melt value yourself. It’s the floor, and some pieces are worth well above it as jewelry.
Have jewelry to sell?
Free to list, 8% only when it sells. Add a few photos and review the draft listing.




